Questioner: What is the purpose of creation?
Ramana Maharshi: Creation is only a mental phenomenon; it is a mirror for “I” to see itself. What is seen outside is only a reflection of the thoughts going on inside; this may not be apparent, but in fact is so. What you call ‘world’ is nothing but thought.
Q: Is the world made up of my thoughts only? The world has a solid existence. My thoughts are within my own head only. How can it be that thoughts create the world?
RM: Mind and world are the same thing.
Q: This world is said to be similar to a dream only.
RM: It is precisely a dream.
Q: How so?
RM: The world vision which appears in the waking state and the world vision which appears in the dream state are both the same. There is not even a trace of difference. Just as in a dream a false knowledge, knower and known rise up, in the waking state the same process operates. What you call “the world” is nothing but sensory perceptions that you are having and such sensory information does not have an external origin. The cosmos is projected by and from your own mind only.
The world does not exist apart from the mind because the world is merely an expansion of the mind projected through the five senses of the body. So,there is no difference between the waking state and dream state, in actual fact. Apart from thoughts, there is no independent entity called the world. In deep sleep there are no thoughts, and there is no world. In the states of waking and dream, there are thoughts, and there is a world also. Just as the spider emits the thread (of the web) out of itself and again withdraws it into itself, likewise the mind projects the world out of itself and again resolves it into itself. When the mind comes out of the Self, the world appears.
If you think you are a finite subject, made of physical matter, living in and spectating a permanently existing, objectively real world, such attitude must go. You are pure Spirit. Appearance of gross matter is a delusion. There is nothing physical at all. What IS, is only Spirit.
Q: So there is no difference between waking and dreaming?
RM: No. Only an apparent one, not a real one. The dream is for one who says that he is awake. Both are unreal from the absolute viewpoint: that which is real must be real always. You create a dream-body for yourself in the dream and act with it. The same is falsified in the waking state. At present you think you are this body and not the dream-body. In your dream this body is falsified by the dream-body. So you see neither of these bodies is real. Because each of them is true for a time and false for other times. The “I-consciousness” is present all through the three states. That alone is real. The three states are false.
Q: Then what is the explanation for the world that I see around me?
RM: The one who apparently sees is the explanation for what he apparently sees.
Q: I don’t understand.
RM: The seer is fictitious. What is seen partakes of the nature of the seer [thereof]. What you see is thus pure fiction.
Q: But what is the actual nature of the world?
RM: There is no world. Absolutely none at all.
Q: But I see a solid world around me! What does Maharshi mean in saying that it is not there? If everything that exists is an illusion, are you real or not? I see you placidly perched upon this sofa. Are you there or not?. Who is talking to me now from the Sofa?
RM: Who is talking to you? Your own mind is talking to you. The Sofa, this body, this hall, the Hill yonder and everything else is inferred existence. Actual existence is not to be seen.
Q: So- even these words you are talking to me right now: its all going on within my head only?
RM: The fact is this: the world is only an idea. Though this world is experienced [as though it were real], and though this world is appropriate or adequate for practical purposes, it is in fact of the nature of non-existence. What is meant by “non-existence”? It means that it has no absolute existence. It exists only in relation to your mind.
Q: But I am seeing you in a physical world, sir. I gather you have already escaped fully from all illusion. How is it then that you still see a world?
RM: I see no world.
Q: Here I fail to maintain pace in my understanding. Don’t you see the couch you are sitting on, sir? Don’t you hear me talking to you right now?
RM: The body on the couch undergoes these experiences. I am not connected with it in the slightest.
Q: But then what about your own point of view, sir? You are independently aware or conscious of being here, aren’t you?
RM: The figure you see before you on the Sofa is nothing more than a figment of your own mind-generated delusory imagination: as is everything else. There is no ‘me’. There is no cosmos. There is no anything. There is only you. You alone exist. You alone could ever BE. You alone ARE. You are the Self. You are the Self. You are the Self.
Q: Where are you then, sir, if not inside the body I am seeing before me?
RM: The Jnani’s abode is the Beyond. He abides as Parabrahman or Jnana Itself. He is the substratum or fabric of Reality in which the world appears and into which it disappears. People ask such questions because when they see a body with life, they imagine immediately that somebody is living within it. [tapping at own right shoulder] There is nobody [living] here.
Q: Whose mind is it that is responsible for projecting the body and the cosmos?
RM: Yours.
Q: Totally 11 persons including B. are now seated in this Hall. Why me in particular and not somebody else?
RM: Only you exist. The perceiver is the imaginer.
Q: Am I the only perceiver here?
RM: Yes.
Q: Do you exist?
RM: No. Only you exist.
Q: That is Jnani’s point of view.
RM: Verily all are Jnanis only. Only to discover the fact is not so easy. Man is acclimatised to identifying himself with body and mind. When told to let go he is frightened because he thinks he will lose himself [thereby]. Realisation is simply the art of letting go of everything [or emptying the mind of all of its contents].
Q: Is Jnana a state of nothingness or nihility, then?
RM: From your present state no understanding about it can be correct. The Sahaja-stithi of the Jnani cannot be imagined with the mind. The Jnani’s state is known only to the Jnani. It is the All and Beyond. Yet It is Nothingness Itself. Yet It is no void but Life Itself. It is Absoluteness Itself.
Q: What a strange view of the world!
RM: We have strayed so far away from the Real that fiction has become natural, whereas Truth has become alien. So, when reminded of the Truth, people become uncomfortable, and refuse to accept it. Given the choice between what is right and what is easy, the lesser man opts for the latter always. Rare is the man who, upon hearing or reading the words, “You are currrently dreaming, the body or mind is not your true Self, Realise your true, illimitable Self.”, feels as though he has been set on fire. He verily is competent to Realise in his incumbent lifetime. One who sees it as a dream may escape rebirth. Others remain ignorant of their true nature and keep wandering around in illusion. But really it makes no difference. Either way you are always the Self.
Q: If everything is a dream how did the dream arise?
RM: Remaining within the dream you are asking this question. Any reply given to you is only going to be a dream-reply. So, the question does not make any sense. First wake up from the dream. Then, if need be, we may ask the question.
Q: How to wake up from the dream? Is it merely the simple Who-am-I?
RM: Yes.
Q:What is the acid-test for evaluating whether I am dreaming or awake at this very moment?
RM: The rule is simple: If anything is being perceived, you are certainly dreaming. On account of arbitrary mental conceptualisations appurtenant to something called ‘time’, we say that these 2 states are different from each other. But again, what is time? Time is also merely a mental concept. Time and space are only our ideas and nothing more. In deep sleep there are no thoughts, and there is no world. In the states of waking and dream, there are thoughts, and there is a world also. What does this invariable concomitance mean?, The explanation is as follows: there is an imaginary “I” which projects the body and the world which is experienced by this body. Both the body and the world proceed from the mind and are projected simultaneously. In deep sleep there is no mind and therefore no projection takes place. Thus in deep sleep one is bodiless and with neither body nor world to be seen. Mind and waking-world are same. Mind and dream-world are same. There is no world of the waking state capable of being perceived in the absence of perceiver thereof just as there is no dream apart from the dreamer; and the dreamer is not apart from the dream. The dreamer himself IS the dream. Dream and dreamer are all one and the same fictitious entity known as “I”. The waking-world or the dream-world is the same as the one who imagines himself to be perceiving it.
Q: So I don’t exist at all?
RM: YOU exist. But that which you take yourself to be does not.
Q: Why do I find it so difficult to believe that the world is a dream?
RM: You need not believe in anything. Only give up all beliefs and ideas, including the belief that there is anything called the world.
Q: How then to establish conclusively for myself whether the world is a dream or not?
RM: There is no use forming theoretical conceptions about the world’s reality or otherwise; No such exercise is possible, because the yardstick of measurement, the measured object, the means of measurement deployed, and the measuring subject are all one and the same mind. That which is now called ‘world’: whether it exists or not and if yes what it really is you will find out only after Realising the Self.
It cannot be proven objectively that the world is a dream, because the objective outlook in itself is incorrect and wrong. You set out to prove with the aid of mind that mind is unreal. It is an impossible, absurd quest.
Q: If proof is not possible, how to believe?
RM: Did I ever ask you to believe? There is no need for any belief. When direct experience is available always, why should anybody want to believe?
Q: Direct experience of what?
RM: The Self. When you Realise your Self, the world disappears as an objective Reality and is seen to be what it really is merely an appearance in the Self. Find out the real ‘I’ and all your doubts will be solved.
Q: What is the Self?
RM: The Self is the Absolute.
Q: How to be the Self?
RM: Abandon ALL belief; destroy everything you think you know about yourself and the world
Q: It is hard to have the conviction within the heart that it is unreal.
RM: Even so is your dream world real while you are dreaming. So long as the dream lasts, everything you see and feel in it is real.
Q: Why does the waking state look so real?
RM: Just like the dream as a dream does not permit you to doubt its reality. It is the same in the waking state, where you are unable to doubt the reality of the world which you see while you are awake. How can the mind which has itself created the world accept it as unreal? While you are dreaming, the dream was a perfectly integrated whole. That is to say, if you felt thirsty in a dream, the illusory drinking of illusory water quenched your illusory thirst. But all this was real and not illusory to you so long as you did not know that the dream itself was illusory.
That is the significance of the comparison made between the world of the waking state and the dream world. Both are creations of (imagined within) the mind, and so long as the mind is engrossed in either, it finds itself unable to deny their reality.
All we need to understand is that whatever we see outside is only our own being-consciousness projected through the lens of our mind and senses. This entire world is an imagination or mental fabrication (kalpana), so when our mind ceases to imagine or project things, they cease to exist. However this should be told only to those who are mature enough to accept it. If we act with the confidence that this entire life is just a dream and that what matters is only attaining self-knowledge, grace will take care of everything else. But until we are mature enough to have such confidence, working to earn a living will seem to be necessary.
